For Sale at La Mesa: 5720 Amarillo Avenue, La Mesa, CA 91942. 6-bedroom 4-bath, 3508 sf, 1980 La Mesa $1,399,000 begin new search
Click a button below to contact Buyers' Agent from Compass. Listing Office: Redfin.
Schedule A Tour Ask A Question Save To Favorites Follow 5720 Amarillo Avenue

Overview

The most unique La Mesa luxury home—offering unmatched flexibility, incredible value, and endless possibilities. This fully renovated home is a rare property that seamlessly adapts to the way people live today. Whether you're searching for a spacious six-bedroom house, four-bathroom home, large family home, luxury family home, or a multifamily home designed for multi-generational living, this exceptional residence delivers incredible versatility. This turnkey home lives like two houses in one, thoughtfully designed with three bedrooms and two bathrooms downstairs and three bedrooms and two bathrooms upstairs. The flexible spacious floor plan can function as one expansive residence or provide dual living spaces with separate living quarters. With its own private entrance, the upper level offers excellent ADU potential and could be ideal for a mother-in-law suite, guest quarters, extended family, or a long-term rental property, creating rental income potential while maintaining privacy for everyone. Each floor has its own central A/C and heating system, making this upgraded home especially well suited for multi-family living and multi-generational living. There is a washer and dryer hookup upstairs, with the ability to easily add one downstairs. Whether you're looking for a multi-family home, multi-unit property, or a large compound this property offers flexibility rarely found in La Mesa real estate. Completely reimagined from top to bottom, this renovated La Mesa home has been extensively remodeled with no expense spared. The luxury remodel features wide-plank luxury flooring, a gourmet kitchen with quartz countertops, beautifully renovated bathrooms, fresh paint, new lighting, and a stunning two-sided color-changing vapor fireplace. Warm mid-century modern influences blend with high-end finishes, natural light, skylights, vaulted ceilings, and thoughtful design throughout. This modern upgraded home offers the style, comfort, and convenience buyers are looking for in a move-in-ready home. Additional highlights include solar, two primary bedrooms—one on each floor—and a smart refrigerator. The extra-wide driveway provides convenient parking for a camper or recreational vehicle. Step outside to a true backyard oasis and private backyard retreat. The beautifully landscaped front fenced-in courtyard features lush turf and charming brick accents, while the expansive rear deck and fully fenced backyard showcase beautiful hill views, canyon views, and stunning sunset views. The oversized backyard features a sprawling turf lawn, pergola, mature trees, and incredible privacy, creating the ultimate luxury backyard and entertainer's home. The elevated rear living area offers a peaceful, treehouse-like setting nestled among the trees, creating a private retreat where you can relax, entertain, and take in the surrounding mountain views. If you've been searching for a view home, this property offers an exceptional combination of indoor-outdoor living and privacy. Located in a quiet neighborhood, this home offers easy access to the greater San Diego area while providing the space and flexibility that's increasingly difficult to find. This one-of-a-kind property deserves a closer look. With six bedrooms, four bathrooms, separate living quarters, dual living spaces, ADU potential, a large backyard, beautiful views, and extensive upgrades, this is an exceptional San Diego investment property and luxury family home with possibilities for years to come.

Address 5720 Amarillo Avenue

La Mesa, CA 91942
Listing Status ACTIVE
Asking Price $1,399,000
On Market Date $1,399,000 @ Sep 9, 2026
Listed / On-Market Entered Sep 9, 2026
Original Entry Sep 9, 2026
Rooms
Primary Bedroom, Primary Bathroom, Bonus Room, Laundry, Main Floor Primary Bedroom, Main Floor Bedroom, Media Room, Office, Living Room, Walk-In Pantry, Family Room, Game Room, Great Room, Utility Room, Retreat, Separate Family Room, Walk-In Closet
Square Footage 3508 sf
Bedrooms 6
Full Bathrooms 4
Location
Directions Cross Street: Mellmanor Dr..
Market Area 91942 - La Mesa
Neighborhood La Mesa
Complex La Mesa
School District Not Listed
Ownership
Age Restriction 0
Property Type
Mello-Roos Fee $0
HOA Fee $0
Listing History
Timeline Notes
Sep 9, 2026Listed for $1,399,000 #260022111SD
Public Records
County San Diego
Assessor Parcel# 4905610100
Zoning R-1:SINGLE
Geographic Areas

Airport Compatibility Zone: Montgomery Field

Community College District: Grossmont-cuyamaca CC

Zip Code: 91942

Highway Locator

East of I-15

East of I-5

North of I-8

East of I-805

East of SR-163

South of SR-52

Ocean Distance 13.0 miles
Exterior
Style Single Family Residence
Material Not Listed
Lot Size ~ 9,100 sf
Fencing Wood,Privacy,Good Condition
Topography Not Listed
Roof Shingle
Swimming Pool None
Patio Patio
Exclusive Yard 1
Parking
Other
Driveway
Total Spaces: 3
Garage Spaces: 0
Non-Garage Spaces: 0 - 3.00
View Mountain(s), City Lights, Neighborhood, Courtyard, Panoramic
Features
Year Built 1980
Laundry Location Gas Dryer Hookup,Individual Room,Washer Hookup
Elevator Not Listed
Cooling Dual, Electric, Central Air
Heating Natural Gas, Forced Air, Zoned
Fireplaces Electric,Decorative,Living Room,Family Room,See Through (0)
Interior Features Balcony, High Ceilings, Living Room Balcony, Ceiling Fan(s), Living Room Deck Attached, Recessed Lighting, Open Floorplan, Stone Counters, Cathedral Ceiling(s)
Additional Parcels No
Appliances Gas Cooking, Disposal, Refrigerator, Free-Standing Range, Dishwasher
Appliances Yes
Assessments No
Association No
Association Fee 2 0
Attached Garage No
Below Grade Finished Area 0
Carport Spaces 0
Construction Materials Stucco, Blown-In Insulation, Drywall Walls
Cooling Yes
Eating Area Family Kitchen, Area, Separated
Heating Yes
Land Lease No
Laundry Yes
Levels Two
Lot Size Source Assessor
Lot Size Units Square Feet
Main Level Bathrooms 0
Main Level Bedrooms 0
New Construction No
Number Of Units Total 0
Number Remotes 0
Parking Yes
Patio Yes
Pool Private No
Property Attached No
Sprinklers No
View Yes
Well Depth 0
Well Gallons Per Minute 0
Well Pump Horsepower 0
Well Report No
Monthly Payment Calculator
Property Tax estimate of 1% of listing price does not include local voter-approved bonds/assessments, supplemental taxes for new construction or ownership changes, extra local fees, etc.
Listing Source
Platform CRMLS
AOR San Diego
MLS Number 260022111SD
Courtesy of Redfin
Listing Agent Katie Gouletas